The Podcast


   
Play
Play
Play
Play
Play
Play
Play
Play
Play
Play
Play
Play
Play
Play
Play
Play
Play
Play
Play
Play
Play
Play
Play
Play
Play
Play
Play
Play
Play
Play
Play
Play
Play
Play
Play
Play
ArrowArrow


Must reads:    All Albums Of The Month   ●   From The Vaults!   ●  The Forums Hall Of Fame   ●   Irish Metal - Reviews Archive
Review

Search




Crowbar
Belfast
Limelight Oct 3rd



Get More From Metalireland

To win albums, gig tickets and access to exclusive stuff that's NOT on the site - join our fortnightly email.





Winterfylleth | ‘The Threnody Of Triumph’


Maybe it’s because they’re contemporaries, arriving at the same moment and playing the same style.

Maybe it’s just cause one’s better than the other. But for me at least, Winterfylleth always come under the shadow of countrymen Fen.

It’s not that they’re not worthy, because they are. Their evocative pagan metal is decent if not spine tingling, and capable though never really cockle-stirring. That was the verdict on their last album, and so it remains with this.

You can hear them trying to be proud, as it were, a lot. It generally takes the form of the major key resolutions and climactic, plaintive ‘wooooooo wooooooooo’ builds (‘The Swart Raven’), as well as some nice fast pacing to make it all a bit more energetic.

After that though, there’s not much left to talk about except two inescapable conclusions: it’s all been done before, and done much, much better. I’d be embarrased to hold this up against the good Drudkh albums, or even something comparitively benign like October Falls or Dornenreich. It never achieves such musical depth – not by a long shot.

It’s all a bit safe, and just a little on the nice side of things. There’s no melancholy, no true aggression, and though the lyrics are barked out in a bracing enough caw, the fact that they’re back in the mix and almost completely uninteligable just detract from whatever threnodies are being recounted.

But then this is pagan / black metal in style, and it’s to be expected.

There are decent moments. ‘A Memorial’, for example, has a major key riff as its main motif that just drips class. So it’s pleasant though slightly boring that its underlying melodic structure is basically adapted and re-run in ‘A Soul Unbound’.

Bottom line is if I had a tenner, I’d buy a Drudkh album, or dare I say even the Fen album before buying this. Though it’s in a style that many will love dearly – that of misty moors and winter fields, delivered in olden tyme, black metal-esque odes – the fact is, it’s boring and it’s been done a million times by tons of better bands.

So it can be as proud and celebratory of heritage as it wants, because sadly it’s got nothing else to talk about.

2.1 / 5 – Earl Grey ::: 28/08/12

This is a track from the previous release – no vids yet for the new one.



9 Comments
  1. You clearly do not know what you’re talking about! THE only bad review of this band that I’ve ever seen.

  2. Well gee, if everyone else thinks it’s great we should all just agree then.

  3. Eoin McLove Says:

    Fen are shite I think. I only have the first release they did and it was dull and obvious. Haven’t bothered with these lads but I’ll give that tune a listen later.

  4. Eoin McLove Says:

    That song ain’t too bad actually. Nothing new but catchy enough.

  5. I quite enjoy this band but haven’t listened to this one yet. From what I’ve read about any of their albums before, the opinion has been fairly split so this isn’t really surprising.

  6. will have to reserve judgement till i actually hear the new album, but the previous two were great, as were the live shows. Be disapointing if this not up to the standard of the previous release…..

  7. Sorry like – it’s just really dull. I agree the last ones had their moments. But its homogenous, samey stuff and simply being a bastion for ‘pride’, ‘land’, ‘heritage’ and all that caper doesnt mean its automatically a listenable or indeed high quality collection of songs.

    There’s a trillion bands have done it, and done it better. The last October Falls album for a start, and that’s before going near the rest of (say) Prophecy’s back catalogue.

  8. wizardinblack Says:

    Had a few listens to the track above, it is too safe and too acceptable and too…nice, for black metal. It’s hard to actively dislike it as it’s certainly by no means shite, but just like the album cover it’s far to comfortable and optimistic.

  9. Cockle-stirring. Chortle.

Post your comment
Name

Mail (will not be published - required)



We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. This includes cookies from the content management and forum systems, Google Analytics for site statistical purposes, Google, Amazon and Ticketmaster for advertising banners and links, our upload widget and Facebook.